What a manufacturing feasibility study has to prove
A plant is a large fixed bet: once the line is installed, most of the cost base is committed whether it runs one shift or three. So the central questions are about volume (how many good units the plant can really make and sell), fixed costs (how much has to be covered before the first dollar of profit) and time (how long the ramp-up takes, and how much cash it burns).
A complete study runs from market and price through capacity, process, site, permits, capital and operating cost, ramp-up, financial results, funding and risk. Market work comes first because every other number depends on volume and price; our market feasibility guide covers that step. The engineering side is covered in our technical feasibility guide. This page concentrates on the numbers that decide whether the plant pays.
The context in 2026
US manufacturing added $3.00 trillion of value to the economy, 9.4% of GDP, in the second quarter of 2026, according to the National Association of Manufacturers. Two figures from the CADDi 2026 Manufacturing Outlook Study matter for any new plant: 79% of manufacturers named the skilled labour shortage as their biggest external challenge (up from 72%), and 69% plan to invest in robots and equipment (up from 60%). Your study should test whether you can hire the crew you need where you plan to build, and whether automation shifts cost from labour to capital.
Step 1: Size capacity honestly
Optimistic models take the rated speed, multiply by every hour in the year and assume it all sells. A defensible study separates three numbers:
- Design capacity is the maximum output at the rated speed for the hours you plan to run. A line rated at 100 units an hour, running two 8-hour shifts on 250 days, has a design capacity of 100 ร 16 ร 250 = 400,000 units a year.
- Effective capacity is what the line will actually produce as good units once you allow for stoppages, changeovers, slow running and scrap. The usual way to estimate it is overall equipment effectiveness (OEE).
- Planned output is the volume you expect to sell in each year, which is often lower again, especially during ramp-up.
OEE: availability ร performance ร quality
OEE multiplies three ratios. Availability is run time as a share of planned production time. Performance is actual speed as a share of rated speed while running. Quality is good units as a share of all units made. A line that is available 85% of the time, runs at 85% of rated speed and makes 90% good parts has an OEE of 0.85 ร 0.85 ร 0.90 = 65.0%.
Two benchmarks are widely quoted, and both are rules of thumb rather than measured industry statistics: an OEE of 85% (90% availability ร 95% performance ร 99% quality) is called "world class", a figure that traces back to Seiichi Nakajima's work on total productive maintenance, and around 60% is often described as typical for discrete manufacturing. Use them as a sense check, not an input. Better inputs are your own OEE on similar equipment, the supplier's guaranteed performance, or data from a reference site.
Check against the national picture
The Federal Reserve's G.17 release reported US manufacturing capacity utilisation of 75.7% in August 2026, against a 1972 to 2025 average of 78.2%. Utilisation is a different measure from OEE, but the point carries over: established plants do not run flat out, so a new plant that must sell most of its effective capacity in year one deserves hard questions.
Step 2: Build the capital cost estimate
Build capital cost (capex) from the bottom up in separate lines, so a reader can see what is included and challenge each one:
| Line | What it covers | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Land and building | Site purchase or lease premium, shell, floor loading, ceiling height, docks, offices | Site quotes, builder estimates, cost guides for factory buildings |
| Process equipment | Production line, tooling, material handling, quality control equipment | Supplier quotations, ideally two per major item |
| Installation and commissioning | Rigging, foundations, mechanical and electrical installation, trial runs | Supplier and installer quotes; often a large share of equipment cost |
| Utilities and services | Power upgrade, gas, compressed air, water, wastewater treatment, ventilation, fire protection | Utility company connection quotes, engineer's estimate |
| Pre-opening costs | Hiring and training before first sale, trial materials, permits, professional fees | Staffing plan and adviser quotes |
| Contingency | Allowance for what the design has not yet defined | Sized to the estimate class (below) |
Building costs: use the right benchmark
Published industrial construction costs usually describe warehouse-type shells, not production plants. Cushman & Wakefield's 2026 industrial construction cost guide, which covers core-and-shell distribution buildings, put small projects at about $144 per square foot (up 3.6%), medium projects at about $87 (up 2.8%) and large projects at about $78 (up 2.3%). A process plant costs more: heavier floors, more power, process drainage, controlled rooms and ventilation all add to the shell. Treat shell figures as a floor and have a builder price the fit-out you need. Our warehouse feasibility guide is the better reference if your project really is a shell building.
Contingency by estimate class
AACE International Recommended Practice 18R-97 classifies cost estimates for the process industries by how much of the project is defined. Its expected accuracy ranges are:
| Class | Typical purpose | Project definition | Expected accuracy range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class 5 | Concept screening | 0% to 2% | Low: โ20% to โ50%; High: +30% to +100% |
| Class 4 | Study or feasibility | 1% to 15% | Low: โ15% to โ30%; High: +20% to +50% |
| Class 3 | Budget authorisation or control | 10% to 40% | Low: โ10% to โ20%; High: +10% to +30% |
Most feasibility studies sit at Class 4, so the true cost could end up 20% to 50% above the estimate and a contingency of a few percent is not credible. State the class, carry a matching contingency, and test the model at the top of the range.
Step 3: Split operating costs into variable and fixed
Break-even and ramp-up both depend on one split: which costs rise with every unit made, and which do not.
- Variable costs per unit: raw materials and components, packaging, the energy used directly by the process, consumables, outbound freight, sales commissions and payment fees. Build them from a bill of materials, supplier prices and a scrap allowance.
- Fixed costs per year: the production crew you must roster whatever the volume, supervisors and management, rent or property costs, insurance, maintenance contracts, base utility charges, IT, quality and compliance, and administration.
Labour is the judgement call. If you need a full crew to run the line at all, treat it as fixed; given the labour shortage, assume you keep a trained crew through quiet months. Price wages from local data such as the Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics.
Step 4: Model ramp-up and working capital
A new plant rarely reaches planned volume in year one: customers must qualify the product, the crew is learning and early yields are lower. Model ramp-up as a share of effective capacity, for example 50%, 75% and 90% in years one to three, adjusted to your customers' approval process.
Working capital is cash tied up in stock and unpaid customer invoices, less what you owe suppliers. Estimate it in days:
- Inventory days, valued at material cost: how many days of materials, work in progress and finished goods you hold.
- Receivable days, valued at revenue: how long business customers take to pay. Use the payment terms your target customers actually ask for, not the terms you would like.
- Payable days: how long your suppliers let you take. New businesses often get short terms at first.
It grows with volume, so it is a cash need in every ramp-up year.
Step 5: Break-even and debt cover
Two tests decide most plant projects:
- Contribution per unit = selling price โ variable cost per unit.
- Break-even units = annual fixed costs รท contribution per unit. Compare it with effective capacity and with each ramp-up year.
- Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) = cash available for debt service รท annual principal and interest. Lenders set their own minimum, and many deduct tax and maintenance capex first.
Our break-even analysis guide covers the formula in more detail, and NPV, IRR and payback explained covers the investment measures that sit alongside it.
Illustrative example: a single-line plant, checked line by line
This is a hypothetical illustration, not a real plant or a benchmark. The round numbers are chosen so every calculation can be checked. Use the method, not the numbers.
Capacity
One line rated at 100 units an hour runs two 8-hour shifts on 250 days: design capacity 400,000 units a year. Assumed OEE is 65% (85% availability ร 85% performance ร 90% quality = 65.0%), so effective capacity is 400,000 ร 0.65 = 260,000 good units a year.
Price, variable cost and contribution
| Per unit | Amount |
|---|---|
| Selling price (ex-works) | $40.00 |
| Materials and components | $16.00 |
| Packaging | $2.00 |
| Process energy and consumables | $1.50 |
| Outbound freight | $1.50 |
| Sales commission | $1.00 |
| Variable cost per unit | $22.00 |
| Contribution per unit ($40 โ $22) | $18.00 (45% of price) |
Fixed costs and break-even
Annual fixed cash costs: production crew $1,500,000; management and administration $500,000; rent, insurance and property tax $300,000; maintenance $200,000. Total $2,500,000.
Break-even = $2,500,000 รท $18 = 138,889 units a year (rounded up), or about $5.56 million of revenue ($2,500,000 รท 0.45). That is 53.4% of effective capacity and 34.7% of design capacity.
Capital cost
The plant leases an existing building. Fit-out $600,000; process equipment $2,000,000; installation and commissioning $500,000; utilities upgrade $400,000. Subtotal $3,500,000. Contingency of 20%, at the lower end of a Class 4 range, $700,000. Total capex $4,200,000.
Ramp-up results
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share of effective capacity | 50% | 75% | 90% |
| Units sold | 130,000 | 195,000 | 234,000 |
| Revenue at $40 | $5,200,000 | $7,800,000 | $9,360,000 |
| Contribution at $18 | $2,340,000 | $3,510,000 | $4,212,000 |
| Fixed costs | $2,500,000 | $2,500,000 | $2,500,000 |
| EBITDA | โ$160,000 | $1,010,000 | $1,712,000 |
| Debt service (below) | $447,088 | $447,088 | $447,088 |
| DSCR on EBITDA | negative | 2.26 | 3.83 |
Debt: $3,000,000 borrowed at 8% over 10 years with level annual payments of $3,000,000 ร 0.08 รท (1 โ 1.08โ10) = $447,088. Year one is below break-even (130,000 units against 138,889), so the plant cannot cover its debt from operations that year. Tax and maintenance capex are left out to keep the arithmetic visible; a lender would deduct them.
Working capital and the first-year cash need
Assume 45 receivable days on revenue, 60 inventory days and 30 payable days, both on material and packaging cost ($18 a unit). In year one: receivables $5,200,000 ร 45 รท 365 = $641,096; inventory $2,340,000 ร 60 รท 365 = $384,658; payables $2,340,000 ร 30 รท 365 = $192,329. Net working capital = $641,096 + $384,658 โ $192,329 = $833,425. By year three, at 234,000 units, it grows to about $1,500,164, so another $666,739 or so has to be funded during the ramp.
Cash needed before the plant pays its own way in year one: capex $4,200,000 + working capital $833,425 + operating loss $160,000 + debt service $447,088 = $5,640,513. With $3,000,000 of debt, about $2.64 million has to come from equity or other funding.
Sensitivity: a 10% lower price
At $36 a unit, contribution falls to $14. Break-even rises to $2,500,000 รท $14 = 178,572 units (rounded up), 68.7% of effective capacity, so year two (195,000 units) only just clears it. Year-three EBITDA falls to 234,000 ร $14 โ $2,500,000 = $776,000, and DSCR to 1.74. A 10% price cut removes 55% of year-three EBITDA. That is why the price evidence matters so much.
A real study from our system: small food manufacturing plant
This is a study our system produced from a sample founder brief, run through the product as a customer would; every figure below comes from its research and financial model. The brief: a salsa and hot-sauce plant in San Antonio, Texas, in a leased 12,000 sq ft food-grade unit with a hot-fill bottling line, selling its own brand to regional grocers and co-packing for small sauce brands. Wholesale about $3.10 a jar for the own brand and about $1.05 a unit to co-pack. Funding planned: $350,000 of owner equity and a $1.1 million SBA 7(a) loan over 10 years at about 10%, a $1.45 million project.
Capacity, from the line's rated speed
The line is rated at 2,400 jars an hour. One shift of 7 productive hours on 250 days is 4,200,000 jars a year at full speed. The study holds sales to a practical 70% of that (2,940,000) to leave time for recipe changeovers, clean-in-place washdowns, maintenance and quality holds. Year 1 plans 1,260,000 jars, three-quarters of them co-packing, which is 30% of the line, and the plan does not reach the practical limit until year 5. Capacity is not the constraint here; selling the output is.
The capital budget, and the lines most plans miss
| Use of funds | Amount |
|---|---|
| Food-grade fit-out, the bottling line (kettles, filler, capper and labeller, pasteurisation tunnel), installation, forklift, lab and IT, permits | $1,093,675 |
| Contingency | $109,368 |
| Opening working capital: ingredients, jars and packaging in stock, and grocer invoices not yet paid | $185,000 |
| Cash to carry the ramp-up (lowest month, month 8) | $477,693 |
| Total funding needed | $1,865,736 |
A food plant buys ingredients and glass weeks before a grocer pays for the finished jars, and it carries its payroll and rent for months before volumes build. The founder's $1.45 million covers the equipment, the fit-out, a contingency and the opening stock; the model's total funding need is $1,865,736, so the plan as funded is $415,736 short, most of it the cash to carry the ramp-up.
Revenue to EBITDA, line by line
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $1,968,750 | $3,019,629 | $4,116,867 |
| Direct costs (ingredients, jars, packaging) | โ$1,079,426 | โ$1,654,015 | โ$2,252,868 |
| Payroll (loaded) | โ$277,308 | โ$492,974 | โ$614,661 |
| Running costs | โ$184,710 | โ$239,091 | โ$297,243 |
| Fixed charges (rent, insurance) | โ$147,653 | โ$153,116 | โ$158,781 |
| EBITDA | $279,653 | $480,433 | $793,314 |
Direct costs take more than half of every dollar of sales, which is normal for co-packing and why volume matters so much. Year 1 carries only part of a year's wages (the crew starts around opening), so payroll steps up in year 2 even as the margin improves.
Debt cover, headroom and demand
Annual loan repayments are $174,439. Cover is at its lowest in year 1, 1.31x, then climbs. The study then shows how thin the early years are: from year 2, sales can fall only 14% before cover drops below 1.25x. It also flags that year-2 sales of $3,019,629 are 53% above the obtainable share the market research supports ($1,970,000). Selling only that share would mean 35% lower sales, far more than the plan can absorb.
Verdict: feasible if restructured
The plant works on its margins (19.3% EBITDA once trading settles), but two things must change before a lender will be comfortable: the extra $415,736 of equity, and signed grocer orders or co-packing letters of intent that show demand beyond the researched share. That is the value of a manufacturing feasibility study done properly. The equipment quote is the easy part; working capital, the cash to carry the ramp-up, and the gap between capacity and proven demand decide whether the plant pays.
Step 6: Site selection inputs
Score each site on the inputs that drive cost and schedule, with written confirmation where possible:
- Power and gas: capacity, upgrade cost and lead time, tariff.
- Water and wastewater: supply, discharge limits and whether you need pre-treatment.
- Zoning: whether manufacturing is permitted, and limits on hours, noise and trucks.
- Labour shed: people with the right skills within commuting distance, and local wages.
- Logistics: freight cost per unit to suppliers and customers.
- Incentives: state and local programmes, usually tied to jobs and capital invested and agreed before you commit.
Step 7: Permits and compliance
List every permit, who issues it, and whether it is needed before construction or before operation. For most US plants:
- Air (Clean Air Act New Source Review). New major sources need a Prevention of Significant Deterioration permit in areas that meet air quality standards, or a Nonattainment NSR permit in areas that do not. Smaller sources usually need a minor source permit. Most of these permits are issued by state or local air agencies.
- Air (Title V operating permit). Required for major sources: generally 100 tons a year or more of any air pollutant, with lower thresholds in some nonattainment areas and for hazardous air pollutants.
- Stormwater (NPDES). Industrial facilities in the categories EPA lists, which include heavy and light manufacturing, need stormwater permit coverage. Most get it through their state; where EPA is the permitting authority, coverage is under its Multi-Sector General Permit. Construction that disturbs one acre or more needs separate construction stormwater coverage.
- Workplace safety (OSHA). General industry standards under 29 CFR 1910 apply from day one: machine guarding, lockout/tagout, hazard communication, and process safety management if you hold highly hazardous chemicals above threshold quantities.
- Local. Building, occupancy, fire and sewer discharge permits, plus sector rules such as food safety registration.
Lead times vary widely with the size of the source, the agency, local air quality, public comment and how complete your application is. Ask each agency for current timelines early and put permits on the critical path.
Step 8: Funding sources to test
- SBA 504 loans finance land, buildings and machinery with a remaining useful life of at least 10 years. Terms are 10, 20 or 25 years, up to $5.5 million per SBA. The usual split is 50% bank, 40% Certified Development Company and 10% borrower, rising to 15% for start-ups or special-purpose property.
- SBA 7(a) loans run up to 10 years, unless they finance real estate or equipment with a useful life over 10 years, and 25 years at most including extensions (13 CFR 120.212).
- EXIM Make More in America Initiative offers EXIM medium- and long-term loans, guarantees and insurance to export-oriented US manufacturing projects; the export share required is 15% for small businesses and some priority sectors, 25% otherwise.
- DOE Industrial Assessment Center implementation grants have offered small and medium manufacturers up to $300,000, at a 50% cost share, to carry out recommendations from a qualifying energy assessment. Check current funding and eligibility before you put it in the plan.
If a lender will review the study, see our guide to a bankable feasibility study.
The risks to test in every plant study
- Volume: slower customer approval stretches the ramp-up. Test a one-year delay.
- Price and input costs: test a 10% lower price and a 10% higher material cost separately, as the example shows how hard price hits.
- Capex overrun: run the model at the top of your estimate class range.
- OEE: test 10 points lower than your base case.
- Labour: what happens if you can only staff one shift for the first six months?
- Single points of failure: one key customer, one critical supplier, one machine with no backup.
Frequently asked questions
What does a manufacturing plant feasibility study include?
Demand and price, capacity, process and equipment, site, permits, capital cost with contingency, variable and fixed operating costs, ramp-up, working capital, break-even, debt cover, funding and risks, ending in a clear recommendation.
What capacity utilisation should I assume for a new plant?
Not 100%. Reduce design capacity to effective capacity with an OEE you can defend, then ramp up over two to three years. US manufacturing ran at 75.7% utilisation in August 2026, against a 1972 to 2025 average of 78.2% (Federal Reserve G.17).
How accurate should the capital cost estimate be at feasibility stage?
Under AACE Recommended Practice 18R-97, a Class 4 feasibility estimate has an expected range of โ15% to โ30% on the low side and +20% to +50% on the high side. Size contingency to the class you actually have.
How do you calculate break-even for a manufacturing plant?
Contribution per unit is price minus variable cost per unit. Break-even units equal annual fixed costs divided by contribution per unit. Compare the result with effective capacity and with each ramp-up year.
Can an SBA loan finance a manufacturing plant?
Yes. SBA 504 loans finance land, buildings and long-life machinery over 10, 20 or 25 years, up to $5.5 million. 7(a) loans can run up to 25 years when they finance real estate or long-life equipment (13 CFR 120.212).
How long do environmental permits take for a new plant?
There is no single answer. It depends on whether the plant is a major or minor air source, the issuing agency, local air quality and how complete the application is. Ask the agency for current timelines early.
Sources
- National Association of Manufacturers, "Facts About Manufacturing": nam.org/facts-about-manufacturing
- CADDi 2026 Manufacturing Outlook Study, via Smart Industry: smartindustry.com
- CADDi 2026 study, via Assembly Magazine: assemblymag.com
- Federal Reserve, G.17 Industrial Production and Capacity Utilization: federalreserve.gov/releases/G17
- OEE benchmarks (rules of thumb, vendor source): fabrico.io/blog/oee-benchmark
- Cushman & Wakefield 2026 industrial construction costs, via Building Design + Construction: bdcnetwork.com
- AACE International Recommended Practice 18R-97: library.aacei.org
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: bls.gov/oes
- U.S. EPA, Learn About New Source Review: epa.gov/nsr
- U.S. EPA, Who Has to Obtain a Title V Permit: epa.gov/title-v-operating-permits
- U.S. EPA, Stormwater Discharges from Industrial Activities: epa.gov/npdes
- U.S. EPA, Stormwater Discharges from Construction Activities: epa.gov/npdes
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1910 Occupational Safety and Health Standards: osha.gov
- U.S. Small Business Administration, 504 loans: sba.gov/funding-programs/loans/504-loans
- 504 loan structure (50% bank, 40% CDC, 10% to 15% borrower), Hazleton CAN DO: hazletoncando.com/sba-504
- 13 CFR 120.212, limits on 7(a) loan maturities: law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/13/120.212
- Export-Import Bank of the United States, Make More in America Initiative: exim.gov/mmia
- DOE IAC Implementation Grant Program, Texas A&M ITAC: itac.engr.tamu.edu